When to DIY and When to Hire a Pro: A Renovation Decision Checklist

When to DIY and When to Hire a Pro: A Renovation Decision Checklist

As a homeowner in Tennessee, the urge to dive into a home project—whether it's giving your Farragut living room a fresh coat of paint or completely overhauling a kitchen in downtown Knoxville—is strong. The promise of saving money and the satisfaction of a job well done can be incredibly appealing.

But the line between a rewarding weekend project and a costly disaster is thinner than you might think.

At Dodson Designs TN, we believe in smart renovations. That means knowing exactly when to roll up your sleeves and when to call in a professional. Use this comprehensive checklist to help you decide!

The DIY Checklist: When to Grab Your Tools

Before you start, ask yourself these three critical questions:

FactorDIY Green LightSafety The project poses no serious risk of injury (no ladders over 6 ft, no major structural changes, no dealing with live electrical).Complexity The job requires simple, repetitive skills and common tools you already own (or can easily rent).Time & Patience You have the dedicated free time (not just evenings and weekends) and the patience to redo a step if it doesn't go perfectly the first time. Mistake Cost A mistake will be relatively inexpensive and easy to fix (e.g., uneven caulk, a misplaced nail hole).

Projects Generally Safe for DIY:

• Painting: Interior walls, trim, and ceilings (prep is key!).
• Minor Demolition: Removing carpet, tearing out old vanity/cabinets (as long as utilities are safely disconnected).
• Simple Installs: Swapping out drawer pulls, hanging curtains, installing basic shelving.
• Landscaping: Planting flowers, laying mulch, building simple garden beds.
• Caulking and Grouting: Re-grouting small tiled areas.

The "Hire a Pro" Checklist: When to Call Dodson Designs

The moment a project touches the "Big Three"—structure, plumbing, or electrical—it’s time to call a licensed contractor. Not only are these tasks dangerous, but mistakes can also affect your home’s safety, value, and insurance coverage.

FactorHire a Pro Red FlagSafety The project involves working near high-voltage wiring, changing load-bearing walls, or requires specialized safety gear. Complexity The job requires permits, licenses, highly specialized skills, or non-standard, commercial-grade tools (e.g., concrete saw, pipe bender).Time & Frustration The job is massive, you have a hard deadline (e.g., holidays), or the thought of doing the work fills you with dread. Mistake Cost A mistake could lead to water damage, fire risk, or structural failure—in short, a very expensive fix.

Projects That Need a Professional:

• Load-Bearing Walls: Any demolition or alteration of a wall that supports the structure above it. (Always hire a professional!)
• Plumbing: Moving or installing new supply lines, gas lines, or drains.
• Electrical: Installing new circuits, adding outlets, or upgrading your electrical panel.
• HVAC: Installing, moving, or repairing your heating and cooling system.
• Custom Cabinetry & Built-ins: Jobs requiring precise measurements, complex woodworking, and flawless finishes.
• Complex Tiling: Large-scale flooring or detailed shower surrounds where perfect water-proofing is essential.

The Tennessee Tie-In: Licensing Matters

In Tennessee, certain trades require specific licensing and permits to ensure the safety and quality of work. When you hire a licensed professional, you are not just buying labor; you are purchasing:

1. Expertise: Deep knowledge of building codes, like the Tennessee Residential Code.
2. Insurance: Protection for your property and the workers on-site.
3. Warranties: Assurance that the work is guaranteed for a period of time.

If you are undertaking a major remodel that increases the square footage or significantly changes the structure of your home, always consult with your local building department in Knox County or surrounding areas.

The Bottom Line

DIY is wonderful for cosmetic, low-risk, and temporary projects.

Hiring a professional is non-negotiable for structural, high-risk, and permanent changes that impact your home's infrastructure and long-term value.

Ready to start planning a bigger project where expertise is key? From design consultation to managing licensed contractors, Dodson Designs TN is here to ensure your renovation is beautiful, safe, and stress-free.

What big project are you dreaming of tackling next? Let us know in the comments below!

‍